In middle-market mergers and acquisitions (M&A), earnouts have become an increasingly popular mechanism for structuring transactions. This contingent payment arrangement, in which a portion of the purchase price is linked to the future performance of the selling company, offers benefits to both buyers and sellers, especially in uncertain economic conditions.
What is an Earnout?
An earnout is a contractual arrangement in which a buyer defers a portion of the purchase price, payable to the seller if the acquired business achieves specified financial or operational targets within a defined timeframe. These targets are typically focused on financial metrics—such as revenue or EBITDA milestones—but can also include operational goals like customer retention or product development.
Drivers of Earnout Usage
Earnouts are used in middle-market M&A transactions for several reasons:
- Valuation Discrepancies: Buyers and sellers may have differing views on the future value of a company, especially in industries experiencing rapid growth or volatility. Earnouts help bridge this gap by linking a portion of the price to the company’s future performance.
- Risk Mitigation: In uncertain economic environments, buyers may seek to reduce their financial risk. Earnouts allow them to protect their investment by tying part of the purchase price to the company’s future performance while still offering a higher valuation.
- Alignment of Interests: Earnouts incentivize sellers to remain actively involved in the business post-closing, ensuring a smooth transition and fostering continued growth. This alignment is critical to maximizing the success of the acquisition.
Implications for Sellers
Sellers can benefit from earnouts in several ways:
- Maximizing Potential Returns: If the business performs well, sellers can achieve a higher overall purchase price.
- Demonstrating Confidence: Agreeing to an earnout can demonstrate the seller’s confidence in the continued success and growth of the business.
- Tax Deferral: By deferring part of the sales proceeds, sellers may be able to spread the tax burden across multiple years, potentially providing greater tax planning flexibility.
- Â
However, sellers must also consider the risks associated with earnouts:
- Achievability of Targets: Sellers need to carefully assess the feasibility of meeting the earnout targets, taking into account potential market fluctuations and operational hurdles.
- Loss of Control: After the transaction, sellers may have limited control over business operations, which could affect their ability to meet the agreed-upon targets.
- Dispute Risk: There can be a risk of disagreements between the buyer and seller regarding whether the earnout targets have been met.
Implications for Buyers
Buyers benefit from earnouts in several important ways:
- Reduced Upfront Capital Outlay: By deferring part of the purchase price, buyers can conserve capital and reduce their initial financial exposure, while still offering the seller a higher valuation.
- Enhanced Due Diligence: The need to establish clear and measurable earnout targets requires buyers to conduct thorough due diligence, gaining a deeper understanding of the business they are acquiring.
- Post-Acquisition Integration: Earnouts can encourage seller cooperation post- acquisition, helping ensure a smoother integration process and ongoing business success.
However, buyers should be mindful of the challenges that come with earnouts:
- Complexity: Earnout agreements can be intricate and require careful drafting to avoid future disputes.
- Accounting and Legal Considerations: Buyers must navigate the accounting and legal complexities involved in contingent payments, which can add to the transaction’s complexity.
Key Considerations for Both Parties
For a successful earnout arrangement, both parties should focus on the following key considerations:
- Clearly Define Metrics: Establish well-defined, measurable, and objective earnout targets that are agreed upon by both parties.
- Thorough Documentation: Ensure the earnout agreement is comprehensive, addressing potential contingencies and anticipating future discrepancies.
- Seek Professional Guidance: Consult with legal and financial advisors to navigate the complexities of earnout structures.
Conclusion
Earnouts are a valuable and flexible tool in middle-market M&A, helping to bridge valuation gaps, mitigate risk, and align the interests of buyers and sellers. An experienced investment bank, such as Crewe Capital, can assist in negotiating and structuring earnouts to help maximize value for business owners. If you would like to learn more about earnouts or other nuances in transaction structures, we would be happy to discuss further.
